Philip Greenspun asks: Should we break up Iraq if so many inside the country hate each other? What are the pros and cons of breaking up Iraq into three regions? A big reason to do this is that smaller nations would be more likely to become dependent on the US and easier to control. It would also reward the Kurds for their loyalty. A con is that many of the nations in the region would get mad at us for doing it (however, they are already mad at us so the downside is limited). What do you think? [John Robb’s Radio Weblog]
We should let the Iraqis decide. Also, it’s a bad idea to refer to the Kurds’ “loyalty.” They aren’t our employees or slaves, they are independent people and as such are loyal to themselves. If people start thinking someone is loyal to them, they’ll just be disappointed and angry when that someone starts to act independently. This phenomenon can be seen in the attitude of Crusaders towards the French for having the nerve to act like a sovereign nation.